💛 A quick favor, if you've got a second.
We're really happy that you chose to read one of our stories and sincerely hope you'll stick around to read more. We took our paywall down — for now — but that won't last forever, and when the gate goes back up, we'd love for you to already be on the inside.
It's free. So please enter your email here and don't forget to like and follow us on all of your favorite Social Media platforms!
Former President Barack Obama on Thursday leveled criticism at Vice President JD Vance, characterizing his political messaging as rooted in ethno-nationalist ideology despite Vance’s marriage to the daughter of Indian immigrants. Speaking with author Malcolm Gladwell about America’s Reconstruction era, Obama drew connections between 19th-century debates and contemporary political divisions, arguing that fundamental questions about citizenship and belonging remain contested today.
Obama contended that one major U.S. political party has adopted rhetoric narrowing the definition of “We the People” to exclude certain groups. He specifically cited what he termed Vance’s “blood and soil version” of that foundational phrase, a reference to language historically associated with Nazi ideology and white nationalist movements. The former president suggested Vance’s framing emphasizes ancestral lineage and length of residence as determinants of belonging and civic participation.
The phrase “blood and soil,” Obama explained, carries implications about who qualifies for citizenship and decision-making authority within the nation. He noted ongoing disputes over voting rights and congressional representation remain tethered to these identity-based questions, though often expressed less explicitly than in earlier historical periods. Gladwell characterized Vance’s position as hypocritical given his marriage to Usha Vance, prompting Obama to acknowledge the contradiction while suggesting it nonetheless represents historical progress.
Obama argued that hypocrisy itself constitutes advancement over outright rejection of egalitarian principles. “Hypocrisy is progress,” he stated, because it reflects acknowledgment that exclusionary thinking warrants concealment. Vance’s July 4 address in New York urged Americans to reject divisive framings of the nation and embrace shared purpose, though he did not directly address Obama’s characterization. Fox News Digital sought comment from Vance’s office regarding the former president’s remarks.
More Stories
Trump Threatens FCC Action Against NBC’s Welker Over Endorsement Coverage
Chicago Mayor Issues Executive Order Requiring Contractor Diversity Disclosures and ICE Ties Reporting
University of Pennsylvania Climate Scientist Demands Supreme Court Packing Pledge From Democratic Candidates