Paul Anka Criticizes Modern Recording Technology, Says Sinatra Would Reject Autotune

Paul Anka voiced sharp criticism of contemporary singers and studio technology during an appearance on Billy Corgan’s “The Magnificent Others” podcast this week, asserting that Frank Sinatra would have forcefully rejected the use of autotune. The 84-year-old musician contrasted modern recording practices with the vocal standards of earlier eras, suggesting Sinatra would have responded with physical fury to such a proposal.

Anka identified Sinatra and Elvis Presley as the two defining “towers” of popular music, crediting both performers with an innate ability to command an audience. He recalled a conversation with Presley in which the rock and roll pioneer expressed admiration for Sinatra’s signature song “My Way,” written by Anka in 1968, though Presley indicated the composition did not suit his musical style.

The songwriter emphasized that successful entertainers must do more than simply perform songs; they must actively engage and captivate their audience. He referenced Bob Dylan as an example of an artist he admires but noted that Dylan occasionally takes the stage without full commitment, resulting in dissatisfied spectators.

Anka stressed that Sinatra’s era demanded perfection achieved through live performance, with orchestras continuing to play until vocalists delivered flawless takes in the studio. He credited Sinatra with establishing an exceptionally high standard that subsequent performers have struggled to match, describing all who followed as “second” to the legendary crooner’s achievements.

Anka also advocated for greater recognition of Sammy Davis Jr., calling him the most underrated member of the Rat Pack and crediting him with superior musical versatility. He noted that a song he wrote for Davis held personal significance comparable to “My Way,” while describing Michael Jackson as an unparalleled talent he never had the opportunity to collaborate with.